A woman has been sentenced to life in prison after being convicted of the murder of her autistic son. Claire Button, aged 35, confessed to the killing of five-year-old Lincoln at their residence in South Ockendon, Essex, on December 15 last year, despite denying the charge of murder. The verdict was delivered by a jury at Basildon Crown Court.
During the trial, testimonies were given by Ms. Button’s husband, mother, two psychiatrists, and the defendant herself. Ms. Button claimed that a voice urged her to end her own life along with her son’s. Following eight hours and four minutes of deliberation, the jury unanimously found her guilty, leading to an emotional reaction from Ms. Button.
The court decided that Button would serve a minimum of nine years in prison. The prosecution raised concerns about her mental health condition and whether it met the standards for diminished responsibility. Details emerged during the trial about Ms. Button’s depression diagnosis in August the previous year and her subsequent challenges.
Lincoln, who attended Bonnygate Primary School, was described as non-verbal and living with autism, developmental delay, and ADHD. Ms. Button, depicted by her family as a dedicated and caring mother, struggled with the pressures of caring for him. The court learned that she experienced suicidal thoughts following an incident at a supermarket on the day of the tragic event.
Lincoln’s body was discovered at their home in South Ockendon. Ms. Button recounted hearing a compelling voice for the first time upon their return. Despite seeking emergency assistance, she felt discouraged by the response time and believed she had to carry out the act.
Psychiatrists provided contrasting opinions during the trial, with one suggesting that Ms. Button’s actions were influenced by psychosis and depression, while another argued that her mental state did not meet the criteria for diminished responsibility. Judge Samantha Leigh acknowledged the complexity of the case, expressing gratitude to the jurors for their service.