Saskatchewan’s Court of Appeal has dismissed an effort to revive a lawsuit challenging the provincial government’s expansion of fossil-fuel power plants. Climate Justice Saskatoon, along with seven residents, expressed disappointment over the decision. They referred to it as a setback but emphasized the ongoing necessity for “climate justice.” The organization reiterated the importance of holding the province accountable for exacerbating climate issues and failing to fulfill obligations to current and future generations.
One of the plaintiffs, Amy Snider, voiced frustration at the outcome, highlighting concerns about the province exceeding greenhouse gas emission limits set by international and Canadian laws. Despite the setback, Snider remains committed to advocating for climate action within the provincial government.
The legal claim filed in 2023 by Climate Justice Saskatoon and seven residents accused the government, SaskPower, and Crown Investments Corporation of violating their Charter rights through fossil fuel-based electrical generation that worsens climate change. The group argued that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms should safeguard their entitlement to a secure climate.
Last year, the government moved to dismiss the lawsuit, which was upheld by Regina Court of King’s Bench Justice Holli Kuski Basset. The decision focused on whether the court should proceed with the case rather than its merits. The Court of Appeal recently upheld this ruling, with Justices Jerome Tholl and Neal Caldwell concurring that the court should not dictate government policy crafting. Justice Julyne Drennan dissented, believing the lawsuit should have continued.
The Ministry of Justice supported the court’s decision to dismiss the appeal, emphasizing the government’s commitment to providing reliable and affordable power to Saskatchewan residents. Meanwhile, a separate climate-related lawsuit by the Saskatchewan Environmental Society challenges the province’s decision to extend the operation of coal-fired power plants beyond 2030. This lawsuit is set for arguments in the coming days. Saskatchewan is the only Canadian province extending coal use for electricity generation, contrasting with others that have phased out coal or committed to doing so by 2030.